A fundraiser can look successful on paper and still leave your group with less money than expected. That is why fundraising commissions deserve more attention than the headline percentage alone. For a busy parent council, team manager, or community coordinator, the useful question is simple: after supporters buy, fees are accounted for, and orders are delivered, how much money will our group actually have for our goal?
The answer depends on the fundraising model. Some programs pay a commission on each sale. Others describe the amount as profit or a share of sales. The terminology varies, but the planning principle does not: understand exactly what your organization earns, what costs are deducted, and what work remains with volunteers.
What fundraising commissions really mean
A fundraising commission is the portion of a sale that goes back to the organization running the campaign. If a supporter purchases a product through your campaign page, the fundraising provider calculates your group’s share based on its program terms.
That share may be a flat percentage, a percentage that changes with sales volume, or an amount tied to particular products. A higher advertised percentage can be appealing, but it does not automatically mean a better result. A program with upfront costs, required inventory, shipping charges that discourage purchases, or extensive sorting can create more work and more financial risk than volunteers expected.
When comparing opportunities, focus on the net fundraising return and the effort required to achieve it. Ask whether the percentage applies to the full product price, whether there are setup or annual fees, and whether any costs come out of your proceeds. You should also confirm how and when your organization receives its payout before sharing a campaign with families.
For planning purposes, use a conservative estimate rather than assuming every supporter will make a large purchase. A straightforward example helps: if your group earns 20% on $3,000 in campaign sales, the fundraising profit is $600, provided no additional deductions apply. The percentage matters, but so does the likelihood that supporters will actually want to shop.
Fundraising commissions versus profit
People often use commission and profit interchangeably, but it helps to separate the two when you are evaluating a fundraiser. Commission usually describes the share paid to your organization from each eligible sale. Profit is the money your group keeps after any applicable fundraiser-related costs.
The distinction matters most when a provider charges fees or expects organizers to purchase inventory in advance. Your group may have a stated commission, then find that supplies, unsold products, payment processing, or delivery expenses reduce the final amount available for uniforms, field trips, equipment, or programs.
A low-risk online model can make budgeting easier because supporters order directly through a campaign page. There is no need for volunteers to collect cash or chase paper order forms. Still, online does not mean hands-off. Your campaign needs a clear goal, regular reminders, and a convenient way for families to share it with relatives and friends.
What to check before choosing a campaign
The commission rate is one part of the decision, not the whole decision. Before committing, look closely at the experience for both organizers and supporters.
First, ask about costs and risk. Are there setup fees, annual fees, minimum sales requirements, or upfront product purchases? A fundraiser with no inventory commitment can be especially practical for volunteer-led groups, since you are not left storing products or covering the cost of unsold items.
Next, look at the products and price points. Supporters are more likely to buy when the products feel useful, giftable, or personally appealing. A catalog full of items people already need can be easier to promote than a product that only a small group of supporters wants. For organizations that value local impact, Canadian-made products can also give supporters another reason to participate.
Then consider fulfillment. Who takes payment? Who answers customer questions? Who packs and ships orders? If orders are sent directly to homes, families may appreciate the convenience. If products ship to the school or organization, the fundraising team may save on some delivery arrangements but take on local sorting and distribution. A hybrid option can suit groups whose supporters have different needs.
Finally, ask how reporting works. You should be able to see campaign sales clearly enough to monitor progress and communicate with your community. Transparent reporting also makes it easier to explain fundraising results to your parent council, board, coaches, or program families.
A practical way to estimate your return
Set your fundraising goal before you select a campaign. If your soccer team needs $2,500 for tournament expenses, start there. Divide the goal by the expected fundraising percentage to understand the sales volume required.
For example, a group earning 25% would need $10,000 in eligible campaign sales to raise $2,500. That does not mean every campaign will reach that amount, and it should not be presented as a guarantee. It gives you a useful target for deciding whether the campaign is a good fit for the size of your community and the time you can put into promotion.
It also helps to consider participation. A school with 120 families might have a different sales pattern than a youth club with 25 families and a highly engaged extended network. Think beyond the immediate group. Grandparents, neighbors, coworkers, and friends can often support a campaign when sharing is easy and the purpose is specific.
A clear message works better than a generic request. “Help us fund new library seating” gives supporters a concrete reason to buy. “Support our fundraiser” is kind, but it leaves people wondering what their purchase will make possible.
Make the commission easier to earn
The most manageable fundraisers reduce administrative work while giving organizers a simple way to promote. At Brightraiser, organizations create a personalized campaign page, share the link or QR code, and earn up to 25% profit depending on campaign sales. We handle online payments, order fulfillment, customer service, sales reporting, and fundraising payouts, so volunteers can focus on communicating the goal.
The process comes down to three steps.
1. Create a campaign around one clear purpose
Start with the amount you hope to raise and what it will support. Mentioning a new set of jerseys, a music program, transportation for a trip, or supplies for a youth activity helps families see the outcome behind the purchase. Choose the campaign timing that matches your calendar. A fixed campaign can create a natural moment for reminders, while a year-round campaign may work well for groups that want an ongoing fundraising option.
2. Share the link where your community already communicates
Send the campaign link through your usual channels, such as school newsletters, team messages, email, and parent groups. A QR code can be helpful at events, meetings, or registration nights. Keep the message short: explain the goal, say what supporters can shop for, and tell them how their purchase supports the organization.
One announcement rarely reaches everyone. A few thoughtful reminders are reasonable, especially near the middle and end of a fixed campaign. Vary the message instead of repeating the same request. You might share the fundraising goal first, then highlight that products are made in Canada, then thank supporters and show progress toward the target.
3. Earn and plan for delivery
As purchases come in, track progress and keep families informed about the delivery arrangement. Direct-to-home delivery offers convenience for buyers and fewer boxes for volunteers. Ship-to-school or organization delivery can suit groups that are comfortable coordinating local pickup. If you choose that route, name one or two people responsible for receiving, sorting, and communicating pickup details before orders arrive.
This small amount of planning protects the supporter experience. People are more likely to participate again when buying is easy, updates are clear, and they can see the connection between their order and your organization’s work.
Questions worth asking a fundraising provider
Before you launch, get answers in writing to the questions that affect your budget and workload. What percentage does our organization earn, and what determines the rate? Are there any fees or required purchases? Which sales count toward our earnings? Who handles payments, customer service, and returns? What delivery choices are available, and what local distribution work will we need to do? When are fundraising proceeds paid out?
There is no single best model for every group. A large school may have enough volunteers to manage a pickup event, while a small team may prefer direct shipping to avoid handling products. A seasonal campaign can fit a specific need, while a year-round page may be better for an organization with ongoing expenses. The right choice is the one that balances earnings, supporter appeal, and the capacity of the people organizing it.
Fundraising should help your group move closer to something meaningful, not create a second job for volunteers. Choose a commission structure you can explain clearly, products your community will be happy to buy, and a process your team can realistically manage. Then share your campaign with confidence and let each purchase do double duty: meeting a practical need for a supporter and helping fund the programs your community cares about.

